Previous month:
March 2012
Next month:
May 2012

April 2012

Paddle Power: Tuolumne River from the Sierra to the Sea

It's time again for Paddle to the Sea, Tuolumne River Trust's epic journey from the Sierra to the sea. Please help sponsor me:


Right now we have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to revive the Tuolumne River. We can bring back the salmon, improve water quality, and enhance recreational opportunities, but we need your help. Please learn more by visiting my site.

Peter Drekmeier
Bay Area Program Director
Tuolumne River Trust
111 New Montgomery, #205
San Francisco, CA 94105
(415) 882-7252 x 302

Oceana Tennis Courts Reopen

You may remember a Riptide thread a few months ago about reopening the Oceana High School tennis courts. I thought then that it was imminent, but although the courts themselves were ready, there was an issue relating to accepting just part of the reconstruction project. I was told (by John Schulz, facilities director for JUHSD) that the courts will open to the public on nights and weekends (i.e., out-of-school hours) from May 1.

Laurie Frater

Federal Judge Stays Conservation Groups' Sharp Park Suit

Click for SF Examiner news story

U.S. District Judge Susan Illston today rejected the City of San Francisco’s attempt to dismiss a lawsuit filed by six conservation organizations over the ongoing killing of red-legged frogs at Sharp Park Golf Course. Explaining that new evidence and recent Fish and Wildlife Service restrictions have called into question San Francisco Park Department claims that the frog population at Sharp Park is growing, the court ordered the city to obtain authorization from the Fish and Wildlife Service for golf course activities that could harm endangered species. The judge ruled conservation groups have legal standing to bring the case, but stayed the lawsuit until October, when San Francisco could face a court trial over Endangered Species Act violations if it does not obtain a federal permit.
“The court’s ruling lays bare the damage golf course activities such as draining water from wetlands exacts on two of the Bay Area’s most imperiled animals,” said Brent Plater, executive director of the Wild Equity Institute. “We expect the Fish and Wildlife Service to require that the golf course cease killing endangered species and propose a comprehensive mitigation and restoration plan as part of any permit.”
The Park Department argued that draining aquatic feeding and breeding habitats for the California red-legged frog and San Francisco garter snake at Sharp Park Golf Course somehow benefits the species. In rejecting these assertions, the court cited contradictory testimony from the city’s own experts and staff that the golf course activities harm and kill protected wildlife.
“The endangered species permit process will weigh the biological impacts of excessive water pumping and habitat destruction to protect one golf course,” said Jeff Miller of the Center for Biological Diversity. “The permit should force the Park Department to change golf course operations to actually protect imperiled frogs and snakes.”
The Park Department has killed endangered frogs six of the past 10 winters, and its so-called “compliance plan” for endangered species has been a complete failure. In February, the department was caught again killing threatened red-legged frogs at the course, draining Sharp Park’s wetlands in a failed attempt to prevent frogs from breeding in their historic ponds.
The Washington, D.C. public-interest law firm Meyer, Glitzenstein & Crystal represents the coalition of conservation groups in the lawsuit.
The Fish and Wildlife Service last year notified the golf course that it was specifically prohibited from handling or moving frog egg masses at Sharp Park and must obtain a permit for any golf course activities affecting protected species. The Service also denied the Park Department’s request to drain wetlands and dredge lagoons at Sharp Park, cynically referred to by the city as “habitat management and scientific studies.” Water pumping, dredging and other activities harmful to frogs can only occur if the department obtains a federal “incidental take” permit with an accompanying conservation plan.
The city-owned golf course at 400-acre Sharp Park in Pacifica is plagued by crumbling infrastructure, annual flooding problems and ongoing environmental violations. More than three-dozen San Francisco community, recreation, environmental and social-justice groups have called for closing the golf course and creating a more sustainable public park at Sharp Park. A 2011 peer-reviewed scientific study by independent scientists and coastal experts concluded that the most cost-effective option for Sharp Park is to remove the golf course and restore the functions of the original natural ecosystem, which will also provide the most benefit to endangered species.
The Park Department has refused to consider this option, and is instead pursuing a plan that would evict endangered species from the site and bail out the golf course’s financial problems with tens of millions of dollars of taxpayer money. The San Francisco Board of Supervisors passed legislation in December 2011 to prevent this from happening, but Mayor Ed Lee, an avid golfer, vetoed the legislation. Further action by the board is expected this year.
Jeff Miller
Conservation Advocate
Center for Biological Diversity
(415) 669-7357


Court Stays Case against Historic Sharp Park Golf Course

SAN FRANCISCO – (April 26, 2012) – Federal district court judge Susan Illston, in a ruling issued Friday, April 26, stayed all proceedings in a suit brought by environmental activists seeking to close the historic Sharp Park Golf Course, owned and operated by the City and County of San Francisco but located in neighboring Pacifica. The order, which also denied the plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment, follows the court's decision late last year to deny the plaintiffs’ preliminary injunction that would have shut down 10 of the course's 18 holes. The case had been scheduled for trial in October 2012.

Sharp Park Golf Course, which is celebrating its 80th anniversary next month, was designed by legendary architect Dr. Alister MacKenzie, who created many of the world’s most hallowed courses, including Augusta National and Cypress Point.  The course is a rarity – a seaside links, created by a master and open to the public at modest greens fees.

“The court did the prudent thing in staying the litigation,” said Bo Links, co-founder of the San Francisco Public Golf Alliance, which intervened in the case in an effort to save the course. “This is the second time that the Judge has ruled against the plaintiffs on key motions.  With the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service considering the City's Biological Assessment for the golf course, it made no sense for the plaintiffs to insist that the court continue to expend its limited resources on their suit. This winter the frogs once again laid a huge number of eggs at Sharp Park, showing that the city’s efforts to improve frog habitat, while at the same time providing affordable recreation to a diverse and vibrant group of local golfers, are working.”

The plaintiffs in Wild Equity Institute v. City & County of San Francisco had filed a motion asking the court to rule that golf course operations and maintenance "take" red legged frogs in violation of the federal Endangered Species Act. SFPGA and the City challenged plaintiffs' standing to sue, opposed their motion, and asked the court to stay the litigation while the Fish and Wildlife Service considers the City’s measures to address impacts to frogs and snakes and their habitat.

In its 19-page order, the court found that plaintiffs had standing, but denied the plaintiffs’ own motion for summary judgment, and granted San Francisco’s request to stay the litigation. The court explained: “As the FWS may issue a Biological Opinion within months that can at least inform, if not entirely moot, this case, and because the breeding season for the Frog will not occur again until next winter, the Court finds this to be an appropriate case in which to exercise its inherent authority for a stay. The stay will allow for the expert agency to review the City’s plan and evaluate the golf course’s activities on the Frog and Snake.”

SFPGA's lead attorney in the case, Chris Carr of Morrison & Foerster, said: “This is good news for supporters of public golf courses in the Bay Area and beyond. It’s also good news for responsible supporters of the Endangered Species Act, rightly concerned that the Sharp Park case could lead any parade of ESA abuse horribles. Because of the city’s responsible stewardship of Sharp Park, golf fans everywhere, including the many thousands who will be attending the U.S. Open Golf Championship in June here in San Francisco, have reason to be optimistic that extremists will not succeed in misusing the ESA to shut down one of golf’s great historic courses.”

CONTACT:  BO LINKS, 415-393-8099,

Sonic Boom from Earthbound Meteor Rocks Norcal: NASA Rockhound Finds Fireball Fragments in Lotus, California

(AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)

About 8 a.m. Sunday a fireball streaking across Northern California and Nevada skies broke the sound barrier, causing a sonic boom that rattled nerves and windows. Scientists say it was a meteor entering Earth's atmosphere and breaking up. Amateur video appears on the Internet and rockhounds have found fragments of the projectile that survived the explosion and landed on Earth.

Click for news story about the findings

One expert says the flaming object was no bigger than a minivan, but it lit up the early-morning sky and hundreds of police and emergency switchboards. Up at Tahoe, where I was attending a class reunion, the meteor was the talk of the lake. Apparently, the meteor was random, not part of the weekend's Lyrid meteor shower.

John Maybury

Earth Day Media Coverage: Share Your Stories & Photos

You made the news! Thanks to Charlene Boysen of Vallemar School for outreach to NBC News.


Thank you to Pacifica Beach Coalition and Earth Day Heroes. Congratulations on the amazing action and celebration that followed. Please keep your stories and photos coming. Your stories should be heard, seen, and shared! Need help uploading photos? Send them to me and I will get them to someone who can help. (Did you think I knew how? Think again!) I also take photos on CDs so I can share them when opportunities arise. Nothing like your story in your own words. Thank you to the many who have shared their projects with me. I have started a document and hope to have the 52 weeks of Earth Day featured in the Pacifica Tribune over the next year. Can happen only if I get your stories and photos.

Pacifica Tribune

Pacifica Patch
From Terra Nova High School Principal:

And, of course, photos and info on our very own amazing website (thank you, Sherry!)

Pacifica Beach Coalition

L Y N N . A D A M S

President, Pacifica Beach Coalition
650.355.1668 Office
415.309.5856 Cell
Monthly cleanups at 4 beaches and more

How to Report Abandoned Vehicles

To report a vehicle parked on a public street and not moved for three or more consecutive days, call police dispatch at 650-829-3939. Before calling, you need this information about the abandoned vehicle: street address or location; make, model, and color; license plate number; how long it has been there. Thank you for your continued strong support of the City of Pacifica crime prevention program. Please have a safe and magical day!
Pete Olinger
Crime Prevention Unit
Pacifica Police Department
2075 Coast Highway
650-355-1172 Fax

Peninsula Progress: New Weekly Paper Covers North County


Victoria Monroe, formerly of the Pacifica Tribune, has launched Peninsula Progress, a new weekly newspaper covering Brisbane, South San Francisco, San Bruno, and Millbrae. Peninsula Progress Is published every Wednesday in print, and is available free at city offices, chambers of commerce, and libraries in all four towns, as well as many coffeehouses and cafes. Contact Victoria at:

Pacifica Fashion Show: Snowy Plovers' Spring Colors



Snowy Plovers don't have a dramatic plumage change in the spring, like Black-bellied Plover or Western Sandpiper, but they do change. The top photo (the one with all the little beach morning glory leaves) is of a male on April 12. The second photo (middle), also of a male, was taken several weeks ago. On today's bird you can see the dark head patches are blacker, sharper, more contrasty. On the bird from a few weeks ago, the crown and back are concolor. On today's bird there is color difference between the back and crown, with the crown washed with cinnamon. This crown color reveals the species' close relationship with Red-capped Plover (= Rufous-capped Dotterel), its replacement in Australia and New Zealand (bottom).

Paul Donahue